Birder's Guide
Hotline / RBA (Rare Bird Alert)        
spacer  Last updated 5/12/08
Hotlines, TranscriptsABA SightingsMailing Lists (listservs) RTWBC Historical Archive
Please if you see these or any other unusual birds!
 Need help with local place names?  See our Local Names Directory.

Olive-sided Flycatcher at Cary IES

From Barbara Butler:  Steve Golladay found an Olive-sided Flycatcher at Cary IES on 5/10/08.   It was in a dead tree along Fowler Road, about 40 yds north of the northern-most entrance to the Cary grounds (south of Nardone Road).  We get only about one report of this migrant each spring.

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Summer Tanager in Pleasant Valley

A Summer Tanager was seen in Pleasant Valley on 5/10/08 but it was not seen again as of 5/11/08. Barbara Butler sent this note to our members on 5/10/08:

This morning Bob Bowler found a Summer Tanager.  Bobbie Post went to see it mid-day and did not find it.  But you might want to try for it. 

Directions: From Rt 44 in Pleasant Valley take North Road (Rt 72) north.  The A&P is on that corner.  Go north for 2.7 miles to Hurley Road on the right. Turn right onto Hurley Road, then turn right immediately onto Woodland Road.  The tanager was seen near the last house on the road.

We only have about 2 county records for Summer Tanager. 

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Western Tanager in Central Park, NYC  - Last reported seen 4/9/08

A Western Tanager, believed to be a female, was found in Central Park on Wednesday 3/26/08. It was identified by Matt Pelikan.  David Speiser posted the following on the NYSBIRDS mailing list on 3/26:

A Western Tanager was found in Central Park today by the Winterdale arch. This is located by the entrance to CP on 81st and Central Park West. Follow the path to the archway. The bird is to left of the arch up the hill a little toward the roadway. It is in a viburnum and appears to be following a Yellow-bellied Sapsucker. Photos I have only posted one so far can be found at the following link: http://www.lilibirds.com/gallery2/main.php?g2_itemId=96

More detailed directions from Tom Fiore:

at...small fenced-in (low green wire fence) plantings with Leatherleaf Viburnum (a large shrub) & White Pine trees immediately west of the park's West Drive, & at the northwest slope along the edge of the old bridle path (cinder horse trail) that goes under the Winterdale Arch (the West Drive is the roadway above the arch) - - - this area is closest to the West 81 Street park entrance, and beginning there take the middle path east (not the one bending slightly right & sloping down a bit) about 150 yards or so to the cinder-surfaced (dusty) bridle path, & follow that to your left, almost immediately arriving at the Winterdale Arch & the plantings noted. The area is but a few minutes walk from the West 81 Street (NE corner) Central Park entrance. Northbound M10 buses stop right there, the M79 crosstown bus across the avenue, & the IND line subway stop (on the local "C" & "B" subway lines) is just across Central Park West as well.

Another version from Lloyd Spitalnik:

The Central Park Western Tanager is still coming to the same Viburnum just above the Winterdale Arch in Central Park. The easiest way to get to the spot is enter the park on W. 81st St and walk the path towards the east. You should easily see and archway that goes below the park drive. The Viburnum is on the left side. Go up the slight hill until you're almost at the roadway. You're now here.

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Northern Shrike at IES in Millbrook  - Last reported seen 3/15/08

William Schlesinger reports that there is still a Northern Shrike present "in the western properties of the Cary
Institute in Millbrook." This is the lowland area.


  updated 3/28/08
Tundra Swan,
White-fronted Goose - another Tundra 3/22

updated 3/28/08  Another Tundra Swan was found at Strauss Marsh by Steve Oresman on 3/22/08 and was last reported there on 3/25/08.  To get to Strauss Marsh, go north on Rt 22, beyond Sharon Station Road. Look for the sign to Webatuck High School on the left. Turn left there, pass the school, and watch on your right for a large pond. You can see it from the road. Bring a scope, if you have one.


Tundra Swan, Stissing Lake
Photo by Debi Kral 3/9/07
Click photo to enlarge

Barbara Butler sent this message to club members on 3/9/08:

The pond between Strever Farm Rd. and Rt. 82 is quite large now and in among the multitudes of Canada Geese are 2 White-fronted Geese, and some pintails. At Stissing Lake is a Tundra Swan. It has quite a bit of yellow on the bill (but not enough to make it a "Bewicks") and has an eye missing. The birds were found by Tom Burke, who called John Askildsen, who called me. Thanks to both of them.

The last time we had Tundra Swans visit the county was in 1995 when four of them were found at Round Pond by Dot Fleury on March 11. They stayed until March12th.

For those not familiar with the locations, here is more detail. Stissing Lake is the lake on your right as you drive in toward Thompson Pond from Rt. 82. Strever Farm Road is on the east side of Rt. 82, south of Pine Plains. It's a u-shaped road that begins and ends on Rt. 82, between the entrance to Mashomack and the road to the old glassworks (aka Craft Pond).

Dot Fleury found a (the?) Tundra Swan at Round Pond on 3/11/08. Round Pond is now privately-owned. The Tundra Swan was still at Round Pond on 3/18. There is a good chance it is the same individual that was seen on Stissing Lake, because it seems to have a problem with one eye.  Also, a White-fronted Goose was seen at Round Pond on 3/19.  For directions, contact Barbara Butler.

Hoary Redpoll in Orange County  - Still being seen as of 3/17/08!

Curt McDermott,  Ken's son, had a Hoary Redpoll at his feeders in Montgomery (Orange County), first on 12/22/07, again January 1-7, 2008, and again from January 12th on. The photos shown here were taken by Ed Coyle in Curt's yard in December.  for directions.

Hoary Redpoll, above and at far left in photo at right.  Common Redpoll is at far right.
Note the obvious heavy streaking on the flanks of the Common Redpoll, which is absent on the Hoary. 

Odd Common Redpoll in Pine Plains  updated 1/6/08

On 1/3/08, Barbara Butler posted an alert about a possible Dutchess County Hoary Redpoll (in Art Jones' yard) to the RTWBC mailing list.  However, on 1/4/08, Barbara posted another alert reporting that several people had gone to see that bird and "the consensus was that this is a Common Redpoll with some sort of problem." As you can see in the photos below, the streaked flanks of the bird are diagnostic, identifying it as a Common Redpoll, but it certainly is an unusual individual.

The bird at left is one of the 30 or so "normal" Common Redpolls at Art's feeders.  At right is the unusual bird that has been with that flock.  In the center photo, Barbara captured the odd "tail up" posture of the bird, in contrast with the normal posture of the other redpolls in the lower part of the image.  Also note the "puffed up" look of the bird, a possible indicator that all may not be well with it.

if you see a redpolls, or any other interesting birds.


Scott's Oriole in Manhattan, NYC - HE'S BACK!  Last reported seen 2/21/08

On 1/23/08, Ardith Bondi posted the following on the NYSBIRDS mailing list:

This afternoon, Wednesday, January 23, 2008, Alice Deutsch led me to an Orchard Oriole in Union Square Park. It was feeding on sap from some Sapsucker holes (Alice saw the Yellow-bellied Sapsucker drill them) and crumbs on the ground in the fenced-in area behind the Ghandi statue. Alice said she and Lenore Swenson first spotted this bird in the same location on December 4.

I have posted four of my photos at http://www.ardithbondi.com/slideshow28.html#0 (scroll from there).

(Numerous photos have been posted since 1/23.  Our friend Lloyd Spitalnik has, of course, done his share - click on his name and take a look at his exquisite images) updated 1/25/08

Responses quickly followed on 1/23/08 with Seth Ausubel immediately exclaiming that it looked like a Scott's Oriole. On the morning of 1/24/08, the bird was observed by a number of people in Union Square Park.  Angus Wilson, Chairman of the New York State Avian Records Committee, stated on NYSBIRDS that "There seems to be good agreement that it is indeed a Scott's. Alvaro Jaramillo, author of "New World Blackbirds" took a quick look at the pictures and comments thus, "This looks like a perfectly fine Scott’s Oriole to me, and I would say it is a young male based on what appears to be fresher coverts and older primaries/Secondaries, in addition to the general plumage pattern." Kudos to Seth Ausubel for his timely revision of the identification."

HE'S BACK! Tom Fiore reported that the bird had returned by 2/20/08

Wednesday, 20 February, 2008 - Union Square Park, Manhattan, N.Y. City - The SCOTT'S ORIOLE has been seen again by a number of observers - in the same section of the park as previously near the southwest corner. That area is immediately north of 14 Street, on the park side of Union Square W.

If you are interested in further discussion of plumage and other details, sign up for the NYSBIRDS messages.

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Northern Shrike at Vassar Farm  - Last reported seen 2/7/08

On 1/1/08, Pete Bedrossian reported: "Just got back from birding at Vassar Farm today. I saw a Northern Shrike there. It was high up in a tree, and was there between 2:15 and 4:00."

Chet Vincent found the adult Northern Shrike again on Saturday 1/5/08. He saw it as he walked in past the gate to the "bluebird field". When he looked across the field on his left toward the Environmental Education Building, he saw the shrike. It was very active, moving back and forth from tree tops to the ground. It was about 3pm. When he walked back past that point at 4pm, no shrike. But then he heard a Great Horned Owl and a Barred Owl as he walked out.

Barb Michelin reported that onthe club's Wednesday walk on 1/16/08 at Vassar Farm, two Northern Shrikes were found. "The first was on the right side of the road past the first gate in the general area reported before. The second was on the left in the trees and bushes behind the Kestrel box."

Location: After you pass the gate (just after the turn to the composting facility) following the road until it turns to the left. Up in the trees on the left side of the path is where the Shrike was today."

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Northern Shrike at Tivoli Bays  - Found & last reported seen 2/2/08

On 2/2/08, Mike DeDea reported:  "An adult Northern Shrike was located near the rail bridge just north of
the Cruger Island causeway at Tivoli Bays WMA today, Saturday, February 2nd. Other birds of note including a 1st winter White-crowned Sparrow and a Rusty Blackbird."

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Ross's Goose in Orange County updated 1/20/08

On 1/17/08, Ken McDermott reported reported 5,000 Snow Geese with 1 Ross's Goose in Pine Island (across the river in the black dirt area) on Skinner Lane. They were seen January 16-17.


Pine Grosbeak in Pawling on 12/30/07  updated 1/3/08

Angela Dimmitt, the compiler for the Connecticut portion of the Pawling CBC, forwarded a note to us on 12/30/07 from Nick Thold, who wrote:  "about a half an hour ago, when I was sitting in the car on Quaker Hill and using the cell phone, I saw five birds fly into a tree at mid plus distance.  At first, I wasn't sure what they were, but when I looked closer at one of them, it was pink with prominent white wing bars.  I drove closer, but a helicopter flew over and they took off to the North.  The tree was at the other end of Church(?) Drive from Akin Hall."

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Say's Phoebe in Westchester County  updated 9/17/07

From Lloyd Spitalnik via the NYSBIRDS-L mailing list 9/16/07:  "Drew Panko just called with news of a Say's Phoebe. It' located at Westchester Community College.  There are 3 ball fields on the west side of campus. The bird hangs out on the fence especially at the north field."
The bird was searched for but not found the morning of 9/17 (thanks to John Askildsen for the update).
Directions from Tom Fiore, as a follow-up:  "Assuming the main campus at Valhalla, Westchester Community College http://www.sunywcc.edu/aboutwcc/maps_directions/maps_directions.htm"

if you see this bird, or any other interesting birds.


Buff-breasted Sandpipers in Orange County  updated 9/12/07

From Barbara Butler via the RTWBC mailing list 9/11/07:   This afternoon, Ken McDermott called to report 9 Buff-breasted Sandpipers at Skinner Lane in Pine Island (Orange County). They were in the two fields past the irrigation equipment. if you see them, or any other interesting birds.

Black Tern at Dennings Point (Beacon)  updated 9/11/07

From Barbara Butler via the RTWBC mailing list 9/10/07:   Tully McElrath has been visiting Dennings Point quite often lately and today found a bird flying erratically over the bay.  After checking field guides, he believes it was a Black Tern, adult, non-breeding plumage.  It was seen about 6pm on Monday.  He's hoping others can find it and confirm it.  

Tully also says that the number of Black-crowned Night Herons has been building and there were more than 20 there yesterday and today.  Green and Great Blues are there too.  The best time to find the wading birds would be low tide, which Tully expects will be about 7am and 6:30pm tomorrow.  He's seen these birds from the opening in the trees by the old pin factory building.

Sounds like it's worth a trip to Dennings Point.   what you find.  It would be a good time to check other Hudson River bays as well.

Wilson's Phalarope in Orange County  updated 8/27/07

On Saturday, 8/25/07 Ken McDermott reported a Wilson's Phalarope from Oil City Road in Orange County. That area is now part of Walkill River National Wildlife Refuge. The bird was seen from the platform, slightly to the left, with a Glossy Ibis. The platform is the trailhead of the Liberty Loop Trail.  The USFWS has a map of the area on its website.  The platform is near the top of the map, where you see the symbols for parking, hiking, viewing, etc. If you go to Oil City Road, please note that the bird may be hidden down a channel or behind some weeds/grass. 

The Wilson's Phalarope was last reported seen on Monday 8/27/07.  Seen with it were a White-rumped Sandpiper, a Stilt Sandpiper and many others. The change in the weather from the heat and humidity on Saturday and the ensuing cold front may have brought the shorebirds in. This week may be the start of a good shorebird migration. If you do find the phalarope, please so we can pass the info on to the Edgar A. Mearns Bird Club in Orange County.

Black Swan in Beacon   updated 8/21/07

On Sunday, August 19 Maury and Miriam Lacher reported that they had seen a Black Swan along the Hudson River at the Long Dock trail.   Black Swans are an exotic bird for our area and are native to Australia.  Some have been reported on the western side of the Hudson River - probable escapees.  If anyone is interested in looking for the Black Swan, Long Dock trail is in Beacon starting at Denning's Point and goes north to the Beacon Train Station.  The swan may still be feeding in the same area.

Bullock's Oriole in Phoenicia updated 3/24/07


Bullock's Oriole, Phoenicia
Photo by Bill Case  2/9/07
Click photo to enlarge

Bill and Elaine Case went with Chet Vincent to see this bird on 2/9/07.  According to Bill, "It was seen behind 13 Tremper Ave from the back yard or 9 Tremper Ave with the owner's gracious permission. The Oriole was going back and forth between 13 and the house with the bird sanctuary sign."
The bird was last reported seen on 3/24.

[posted on 2/6/07 by Rich Guthrie on the Mid-Hudson Birds mailing list]...An adult male BULLOCK'S ORIOLE has been paying infrequent, but daily, visits to feeders in a yard in Phoenicia, Ulster County. According to the homeowner, the bird has been "around all winter". Further elaboration suggests that he has been visiting since sometime in October or November.

The homeowner requests that her address not be publicized and that birders not come directly to her house.
 
The good news is that the bird has been around for a long time, and has managed to survive some bitter cold nights of late. As stated, the bird pays infrequent visits to a suet feeder in the one yard. Obviously he spends more time and roosts elsewhere - whereabouts unknown.
 
The oriole makes sporadic, short visits to that particular yard - but apparently not until mid morning. There are lots of possible sites other than that yard to search for the oriole. I spoke with some to the neighbors, finding them amenable to the prospects of other birders searching up and down the neighborhood streets. Of note, I didn't speak with everyone in the area, so a judicious approach would be prudent.
 
Directions: NYS Thruway to Kingston Exit – Rt 28 to Phoenicia – From Downtown Phoenicia Rt 214 one country block to Tremper Ave. The oriole has known to have been seen in a rear yard along Tremper Avenue which is one block away from Main Street Phoenicia along NYS Rt. 214. There is a firehouse with a flagpole on the Rt. 214 corner. When last seen today [2/6/07], it was in shrubbery in front of a yard facing Tremper Ave. Another possibility would be to cruise yard-side vegetation along the next street which would be Romer Street......From Rich Guthrie 3/2/07: View the feeder stations behind 21 Tremper from firehouse parking area or along Tremper or other nearby streetside shrubbery. She welcomes comments, compliments, and kudos. If she knows you’re looking for the bird, she will keep the dogs inside for a while. 

Please if you find these or any other unusual birds!

Smith's Longspur at Jones Beach updated 3/29/07
A Smith's Longspur was found at Jones Beach on February 9th.  It has been seen near the Teddy Roosevelt Nature Center. Allan and Barbara Michelin went to see it on the 11th. The bird was last reported seen on 3/18. The bird has been feeding with some Horned Larks in the western portion of the shell lot west of the TR Nature Center at Jones Beach West End (Nassau Co.). Look from the paved lane along the northern edge of the shell or swale for the bird.

Please if you find these or any other unusual birds!

Western Tanager in Baldwin, NY (Long Island)        updated 4/2/07
[from Barbara Michelin]...Debi Kral reported on the Mid-Hudson Birds mailing list that a male Western Tanager has been visiting feeders in a yard in Baldwin. Debi took photos of the bird over the weekend. If you are going to see the Smith's Longspur at Jones Beach, you can easily combine a visit to Baldwin in the same trip. John and Muriel Stahl, the property owners, are birders themselves and are very birder friendly. John indicated the bird is there most regularly in the morning and then intermittently in the the afternoon. Breeding plumage seems to be developing, the blush has become more pronounced. The bird was last reported seen on 3/30 (but not on 3/31).

From Brendan Fogarty on 2/11/07 on NYSBIRDS-L:  The male Western Tanager was seen by many today at a private house in Baldwin. See directions below. The very friendly home owners welcome birders, but they wish to keep all visits between 10 AM and 4 PM. They say the bird frequents the back deck more often in the morning, with wider intervals in the afternoon. The bird is slowly transitioning into breeding plumage: currently red is clearly visible on the forehead. Also in the yard: a single Hermit Thrush, a Carolina Wren, the usual suspects, and 30 Mallards, who may amusingly be summoned with a quack. From Sunrise highway, go north on Milburn Ave. for a short distance, under the LIRR, and make a right on McKenna (right before Milburn merges with Grand Avenue, there is a Valero gas station at this corner). Take McKenna 3 blocks to its end, park, and go to 2049 Windsor Rd. From Grand Ave, heading south, take Milburn when it splits at the Valero station, and take the first left (McKenna).

Please if you find these or any other unusual birds

Ivory Gull (and Snowy Owl) in Piermont  updated 4/10/07
An Ivory Gull was found on February 25th in Piermont by Gene Herskovics, who had gone there to see the Snowy Owl that has been there for almost 2 months. The Ivory Gull was last reported seen on 2/26.  Many, many people looked for it on (and after) the 27th but it was not found. The Snowy Owl disappeared for 18 days and was then again reported seen starting 3/29.  According to Alan Wells of the Rockland Audubon Society, "Drew Ciganek reported seeing the owl Thursday evening ( 3/29/07) bathing and visiting its usual perches around the old ferry slip. Drew checks the pier nearly every day. This is his first sighting of the bird since March 10."     The Snowy Owl was last reported seen on 4/7. 

Directions from John Askildsen on 2/26/07 on NYSBIRDS-L:

From NJ/GWB: Pallisades ISP'way N to Rte 9W Exit @ "State Line". Proceed up Rte 9W north into Rockland County, NY, through Tallman and Sparkill to Piermont. Look for Sharp right turn onto "Broadway", which is on a steep hill going down to Piermont Village and the Pier buisness district. There may be a "Buisness District" sign on northbound Rte 9W, with an arrow, pointing down hill onto Broadway. There is one Southbound on Rte 9W.

From the north, take NYS Thruway to the Rte 9W Nyack exit, which is the last in Rockland, before venturing onto the Tappan Zee Bridge. Follow Rte 9W south to Piermont and then take Broadway down into Piermont Village. Piermont is 2-3 miles south of the TZ Bridge.

Once down at the foot of B'Way in Piermont Village, basically you want to go straight ahead to the little park, which is bordered by the Condos on the east, new retail commercial buildings on the south, and the concrete bulkhead and promenade on the north. It is here where the gull roosted on the ice with 60 plus Ring-billeds. There is an ice covered little bay there.

Today, if the bird returns in the snow fall we're getting, it could be in the same location, or perhaps on the south side of the pier. Just look for the gull flocks.

Long Islanders may find the Rte 95/GWB/Pallisades ISP'way approach an easier,quicker route.

Please if you find these or any other unusual birds!

  Hotline Archive Index

Additional Hotline Resources

Calling a Hotline Number For information on interesting bird sightings, you may want to call one of the many hotlines that make up the NARBA (North American Rare Bird Alert) network. Listed below are the numbers that cover southeastern New York. For a comprehensive list, visit the Peterson Online site.

Hudson-Mohawk (Albany) Region (Kingbird Region 8)
phone: 518-439-8080 compilers: John Saville, Jeff Marx, Jackie Bogardus, Rich Guthrie, Lou Esch

Lower Hudson Valley Region (Kingbird Region 9)
phone: 914-666-6614 compiler: New compiler is needed, so this RBA is not currently active.

New York City and Long Island Region
(Kingbird Region 10)
phone: 212-979-3070 compiler: Tom Burke

Connecticut
7/18/06   Please note, there is no telephone hotline anymore.  Check out CTBIRD which you can subsctibe to for automatic alerts to your mailbox.

Viewing Hotline Recording Transcripts Online

You can view hotline transcripts online at The Virtual Birder. When you get there, just click on the state that interests you.

American Birding Association "Sightings" Column  5/15/06

The newly expanded "Sightings" column in the ABA's Winging It newsletter is a timely, comprehensive summary of rarity news in North America.  Written by Rick Wright, with expert consultants Jon Dunn and Paul Lehman, the column is now available online at http://www.americanbirding.org/pubs/wingingit/archives/vol18no2p16to17.pdf

Mailing Lists (last updated 3/18/03)

MidHudsonBirds provides a forum for the discussion, communication, and reporting of wild bird observations in the Ulster, Dutchess, Greene, and Columbia County areas of New York State, including the Catskill and Shawangunk Mountains. Related natural history observations within this geographical area, and relevant posts from outside of this area are also welcome. To join, or to learn more, visit http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MidHudsonBirds/
 

NYSBIRDS-L provides a discussion forum for birders in New York to share their observations and knowledge. Recent postings of NYSBirds are available on Jack Siler's Birding on the Net site, or you can subscribe by sending an e-mail to:
with the following in the body of the message (substituting your own name):
subscribe NYSBIRDS-L Firstname Lastname

Regional digests called BIRDEAST, BIRDCNTR, and BIRDWEST are created and distributed free via e-mail to subscribers. These contain transcripts (or highlights of transcripts) of hotline recordings. Searchable archives of these notes are available on the web:

BIRDEAST archive
BIRDCNTR archive
BIRDWEST archive

If you'd like to get the RBA transcripts automatically in your e-mail box, you can join the BIRDEAST mailing list by filling out a form online.

  RTWBC Historical Archive Index
©2001-2008 Ralph T. Waterman Bird Club, Inc. and its Licensors
All photos are copyright of the respective photographers
and may not be used without written permission.